Thursday, January 9, 2025

'The costliest fire on record'

Los Angeles fires test stopgap insurer
Bloomberg
Leslie Kaufman for Green Daily

Los Angeles plunged into its worst natural disaster in decades as wildfires driven by hurricane-strength wind gusts tore through prosperous neighborhoods, killed at least five people and forced more than 100,000 residents to flee. Keep up with the latest news on Bloomberg.com.

Today's newsletter looks at the fallout so far. Read first on how this expensive wildfire could put a $5 billion hole in the state-sponsored home insurer of last resort. Later, see how the disaster is reviving the debate over private firefighters, and learn more about the role climate change is playing in the fires. 

Los Angeles fires become an existential test

By Leslie Kaufman

The conflagrations tearing across Los Angeles are on track to be among the most expensive wildfire disasters in US history, draining insurance coffers and threatening California's massive state-sponsored insurance program.

Losses from the fires "could push insurance markets over the brink in California," said Michael Wara, a senior researcher for climate and energy at Stanford University and a wildfire expert. 

It's an unprecedented test of the FAIR plan, the state-sponsored insurer of last resort. Pacific Palisades is the high-cost neighborhood at the center of the Palisades Fire. The FAIR plan has seen its exposure there skyrocket to $5.89 billion. Its policies in one ZIP code central to Pacific Palisades grew 85% between 2023 and 2024.

Read More: 'Insurers of Last Resort' Are Absorbing Trillions in Housing Risk

At least three fires continued to spread rapidly on Wednesday, more than a day after the initial fire outbreak. The Palisades Fire destroyed 300 structures and 13,306 remain threatened.  The Hurst Fire, burning northwest of Los Angeles and Burbank, has threatened another 40,000 buildings, while the Eaton Fire burning near Pasadena has endangered more than 28,000 structures.

Vehicles burn during the Eaton Fire in Altadena on Jan. 8. Photographer: Jill Connelly/Bloomberg

"It is plausible that the Palisades Fire in particular will become the costliest fire on record, period. Not just in California, but in general," said Daniel Swain, a University of California Los Angeles climatologist, in a briefing on Wednesday.

Long before the Palisades erupted in flames, the multimillion dollar homes in the area had become a concern to major insurers. That's because the homes are both extremely expensive and tightly packed together, which makes it easy for fires to jump from one property to another. The neighborhood is also located along steep canyons, which makes it less accessible for firefighters.

The rise of massive wildfires in the state over the last several years has been exacerbated by climate change. Droughts have become more frequent as temperatures rise. The Los Angeles area has had no meaningful rain for many months, despite the fact that winter is usually the rainy season. The enormous volumes of claims following recent fires has taken a toll on insurers. Seven out of the 12 biggest home insurers have limited their coverage in California over the past two years, driven in part by increased fire risk.

State Farm General Insurance Co., California's largest property insurer, announced in March that it would not renew 72,000 home and apartment policies statewide. Pacific Palisades was hit particularly hard. The agency canceled 69% of its policies in the neighborhood's 90272 ZIP code. 

In a statement, State Farm said: "Our number one priority right now is the safety of our customers, agents and employees impacted by the fires and assisting our customers in the midst of this tragedy."

When Californians can't find a traditional insurer to sell them a policy, they can turn to the FAIR Plan. In September, FAIR listed its exposure as $458 billion, up 61% from the previous year. 

A vehicle burns during the Eaton Fire. Photographer: Jill Connelly/Bloomberg

Wara at Stanford warned that the state-run insurer does not have the basic infrastructure of assessors and personnel to handle claims. But the bigger question is whether the state can pay for resulting claims.

Reinsurance — or the insurance policies purchased by insurers to backstop claims — is in short supply. In testimony last year, the FAIR plan reported it had only about $2.5 billion in reinsurance and $200 million in surplus cash.  If the fires continue to expand and destroy buildings, the damage could top the amount of resources the state-run plan has to pay claims. 

Get the full story on Bloomberg.com. Also, read Bloomberg Green's investigation into the trillions of dollars in risk insurers of last resort are absorbing in places most prone to wildfires and hurricanes. The story is part of our Uncovered series

Expensive disaster

$52 billion
The Los Angeles wildfires will cause at least this much in damage and economic loss, making it one of the costliest natural disasters in US history, according to a preliminary estimate.

Staggering destruction

"This is already one of the worst wildfires in California history. Should a large number of additional structures be burned in the coming days, it may become the worst wildfire in modern California history based on the number of structures burned and economic loss."
Jonathan Porter
AccuWeather's chief meteorologist
In addition to the human costs and property damage in Los Angeles, there will likely be longer-lasting health impacts due to acrid smoke, as well as a dent in the region's lucrative tourism business, AccuWeather said.

Data check

The debate over private firefighters for the rich

By Todd Woody and Maxwell Adler

As his Los Angeles neighborhood burned on Tuesday, resident Keith Wasserman posted a plea on X: "Does anyone have access to private firefighters to protect our home in Pacific Palisades? Need to act fast here. All neighbors houses burning. Will pay any amount."

Wasserman, cofounder of real estate investment firm Gelt Venture Partners, sparked outrage online, renewing debate about the role of private fire-fighting services as increasingly fast-moving, climate-driven wildfires overwhelm governments' ability to respond. Wasserman's X account has since been deleted and he didn't respond to a request for comment. 

Private firefighters were being deployed in Los Angeles as several wildfires continued to burn out of control on Wednesday, incinerating more nearly 30,000 acres, forcing tens of thousands of people to evacuate and destroying more than 1,000 structures. But the role of private firefighters and their effectiveness in an era of catastrophic conflagrations isn't clear cut. 

Houses burn during the Palisades Fire in the Pacific Palisades neighborhood. Photographer: Kyle Grillot/Bloomberg

The hurricane-force winds that drove the extreme speed of the Palisades fire and forced residents to flee for their lives would have left little time for private fire-fighting teams to respond, according to Don Holter, an owner of Mt. Adams Wildfire, a Northern California fire-fighting service. 

"With those kind of winds, the fire is coming straight at you and there's nothing you can do to stop it." Holter said. 

Private fire-fighting services for hire have drawn criticism in recent years. When Kim Kardashian and Kanye West credited private firefighters with saving their $60 million Los Angeles mansion from a 2018 wildfire, the move was seen as a sign of widening inequality, with the rich paying to protect their property with everyone else left to sift through the ashes. 

Covered 6, a Los Angeles-area security firm, is assisting cities with evacuations and fire suppression, according to company founder Chris Dunn. "There is no replacing, or circumventing, or subverting public safety," said Dunn. "There's only augmentation and support."

Read the full story on Bloomberg.com.

What else we know

What role is global warming playing in the fires? A stubborn high-pressure ridge has blocked moisture from reaching Southern California for months, creating a virtual force field that has led to dry conditions. Researchers say prolonged fall and winter dry spells are likely linked to warming oceans, which can cause the jet stream — the band of fast-moving winds that control weather across North America — to wander off its usual track. That leaves high-pressure ridges stuck in place. It's another example of how a warming world wreaks havoc with weather. 

Why is wind creating a problem for containing the blazes?  Earlier this week, firefighting aircraft were grounded due to intense winds, hampering efforts to combat the wildfires. Powerful Santa Ana winds have also been fueling dangerous fire behavior in the Los Angeles area and were the main culprit behind the spread of the Malibu fires in December. Read more about the Santa Ana winds here

What's the next step in the firefight? Officials are under immense strain to contain the fires, which have scorched some 27,000 acres, upending life in America's second-largest city. On Thursday US Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin said the Pentagon is ready to provide aircraft to help extinguish the flames from the sky. "Many US military installations in the area have personnel and equipment that can also be surged to fight this awful blaze," he said.

For weather insights sent straight to your inbox, subscribe to the Weather Watch newsletter.

Climate change is speeding up

By Eric Roston

Scientists sounded the alarm long before last year ended that 2024 would become the hottest year on record and almost certainly the first to surpass the 1.5C limit to global warming, set out as a goal in the Paris Agreement. Now both of those milestones are expected to be confirmed on Thursday and Friday in official statistical releases from scientific agencies, including the US National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration and the UK Met Office.

What's puzzled scientists is the clear acceleration in rising temperatures, even as the evidence of the fast-warming atmosphere became impossible to miss.

The hottest day ever recorded happened on July 21, 2024 — a record that held until July 22. The planetary heatspike was made 2.5 times more likely by greenhouse gases, according to researchers. Typhoon Gaemi in Asia and Hurricanes Helene and Milton in the US, similarly juiced by climate change, killed hundreds of people and caused colossal damage. There was flooding across Africa's Sahel and in southeastern Spain; drought in southern Italy and the Amazon River basin; wildfires in central Chile; and landslides in northern India.

Hottest-year status, awaiting confirmation, would put 2024 in rarefied company. The warmest year up to now, by a substantial margin? 2023.

But while the heat is clear, scientists are struggling to account for the speed of this recent jump. Something's pushing up temperatures faster than expected, and the climate detectives have yet to agree on what. After months of research and debate, they have collected suspects — and already let a few go — in what's become the greatest climate mystery in 15 years.

"The science tells us that we should expect surprises like this," said Sofia Menemenlis, a Ph.D. candidate in atmospheric and oceanic sciences at Princeton University. "This is not something that should be completely unexpected in the future, knowing what we know about global warming."

Read the full story on Bloomberg.com 

Last year's catastrophes were the costliest since 2017. At $140 billion, insured losses from natural disasters globally were more than double the 30-year average of roughly $60 billion, according to industry data compiled by Munich Re and published in a report. 

Fires aren't the only natural disaster to worry about. Flooding poses the greatest threat to supply chains this year, as warm ocean temperatures fuel more frequent and disruptive storms, including powerful hurricanes, according to a report from Everstream Analytics.

Is there any good news? US greenhouse gas emissions and economic activity typically grow in tandem. But there are indications that the two are beginning to diverge, in an optimistic sign for the climate.

Listen in

In December, Europe's Copernicus weather service announced that it was "virtually certain" that 2024 would be the hottest year ever. What's more, the global average temperature last year appears to have surpassed 1.5C for the first time, blowing past a threshold that's taken on enormous significance in the fight against climate change. Does that mean governments, corporations, and activists recalibrate their climate goals? Akshat Rathi speaks with reporters Eric Roston and Zahra Hirji about what this new reality means. Listen now, and subscribe on Apple,  Spotify, or YouTube to get new episodes of Zero every Thursday.

Worth your time

Carbon offsets — a controversial tool companies use to try and make up for emissions — could be worth as much as $1 trillion by 2050, according to Bloomberg NEF. But this lucrative sector has problems. Already plagued by dubious claims known as greenwashing, it faces new challenges like those at Indonesia's Rimba Raya, one of the largest carbon offset projects in the world. Watch the latest video from Bloomberg Originals on the fight for a share of this $1 trillion market in Borneo's jungle.

More from Bloomberg

  • Hyperdrive for expert insight into the future of cars
  • Energy Daily for a daily guide to the energy and commodities markets that power the global economy
  • CityLab Daily for top urban stories and ideas, curated for your inbox by CityLab editors
  • Tech Daily for what to know in tech

Explore all Bloomberg newsletters at Bloomberg.com.

Follow Us

Like getting this newsletter? Subscribe to Bloomberg.com for unlimited access to trusted, data-driven journalism and subscriber-only insights.


Want to sponsor this newsletter? Get in touch here.

You received this message because you are subscribed to Bloomberg's Green Daily newsletter. If a friend forwarded you this message, sign up here to get it in your inbox.
Unsubscribe
Bloomberg.com
Contact Us
Bloomberg L.P.
731 Lexington Avenue,
New York, NY 10022
Ads Powered By Liveintent Ad Choices

No comments:

Post a Comment

Sputter out of China won't turn things around

Emerging markets are 10% down from their October peak. It's mostly China's fault. Rising bond yields are miserable, but they...