Tuesday, November 5, 2024

American exceptionalism, now with more oil

Can an oil nation be a climate leader?

Americans are heading to the polls today, and while the presidential candidates have extremely different views on the US's role in combating climate change, they are vying to lead a country that is now the world's No. 1 producer of oil. Today's newsletter looks at how this impacts the credibility of the US at international climate negotiations. 

You can read this story — and all COP29 coverage — for free on Bloomberg.com. For unlimited access to climate news and data, please subscribe

Can an oil nation be a climate leader? 

By Kevin Crowley

It sounded like the top American climate diplomat really meant it: "We are moving away from fossil fuels," said John Kerry, in one of his last acts as the US negotiator at the close of last year's United Nations climate summit. "We're not turning back."

Today, the US is producing more oil than any other country in history. Further increases to US output are planned next year and beyond, no matter who prevails in the presidential election being held days before climate diplomats convene for COP29 in Azerbaijan. The rising tide of American oil doesn't just contradict Kerry's pledge; it cuts against authoritative projections by the International Energy Agency and other analysts who conclude no new fossil fuel fields should be built if the world wants to hit net zero in the next 25 years.

"No country can show up to the international stage and claim to be a climate leader while continuing massive fossil fuel expansion back at home," said Catherine Abreu, director of the International Climate Politics Hub, which works with member states at COP meetings. "The US is the most significant culprit, but there are many other countries embedded in this kind of hypocrisy."

The US currently pumps 13.5 million barrels a day, more than 50% more than Saudi Arabia. And it's directly challenging the Kingdom's hegemony as the "central bank of oil" by taking a commanding position in the market.

If that wasn't enough, the US recently became the world's biggest exporter of liquefied natural gas, jumping ahead of Australia and Qatar after flooding the market at home. American gas executives are scouring the world for new markets, locking buyers into fossil fuels for decades to come.

A curious fact about the US emergence as the dominant oil power is that it has coincided with a period of pronounced climate leadership. President Joe Biden will leave the White House after reintegrating the world's biggest economy into the international climate order and passing landmark legislation to spend hundreds of billions of dollars on green technologies. Kerry and John Podesta, the former and current climate envoys, play central roles in negotiations and have won significant commitments to reduce planet-warming emissions, including from China.

John Kerry, right, then serving as US climate envoy, speaks with his Chinese counterpart Xie Zhenhua during the COP28 summit in Dubai last year. Photographer: Hollie Adams/Bloomberg

For how long will US officials be able to simultaneously call climate change an "existential threat" to humanity while pumping all this oil and gas?

"It's kind of accepted that someone like Saudi Arabia is not a good actor in climate talks," said Collin Rees, campaign manager for Oil Change US. "But the US is responsible for more fossil fuel expansion than anyone else. It's a core contradiction that the US will have to confront sooner rather than later."

That tension is clearly visible in the aftermath of COP28 in Dubai, where the US helped secure the first-ever global agreement to transition away from all fossil fuels. Yet US oil production has jumped 24% over the last four years and will increase another 6% to 14.1 million barrels a day by 2026, according to BloombergNEF forecasts. That's more than the daily output of Iraq, Iran, Kuwait, Nigeria and Venezuela — combined. The Department of Energy expects exports of liquified natural gas to double by 2030.

While the result of the upcoming presidential election could have enormous consequences for US participation in international climate agreements, little should change in terms of producing oil and gas. Democratic candidate Kamala Harris and Trump have made it clear oil executives will have a friend in the White House. Trump, who withdrew from the Paris Agreement on climate change in 2017, is close to the industry and has promised to slash regulations to enable higher production and lower energy prices. Harris has reversed her pledge to ban fracking while campaigning in the previous presidential election cycle and frequently touts the country's record oil and gas production in her stump speeches.

Harris insists she supports the fight against climate change. In fact, she's tried to balance the apparent contradiction between being the leading oil exporter and a climate leader. "I am proud that as vice president over the last four years, we have invested a trillion dollars in a clean energy economy while we have also increased domestic gas production to historic levels," she said in a debate with Trump in September.

In the energy world, this is known as an all-of-the-above policy that promotes fossil fuels, renewable energy from solar and wind as well as novel forms of emissions mitigation such as carbon capture. Exxon Mobil Corp. calls it "the 'and' equation," and this flexible rhetoric fits in comfortably at climate summits. Exxon Chief Executive Officer Darren Woods used a surprise appearance last year at COP28 in the oil hub of Dubai to argue for a broader conversation "to meet the needs of society and reduce emissions," rather than simply shutting down fossil fuels. Woods is expected to turn up again this month at COP29 in Baku.

Exxon Mobil CEO Darren Woods made a surprise appearance at COP28 in Dubai, and he's expected to be back at COP29 in Azerbaijan this month. Photographer: Hollie Adams/Bloomberg

Notably, the final text agreed to by every nation at COP28 recognized the need for "transitional fuels," a term of art favored by fossil fuel lobbyists and widely interpreted as a crucial defense of natural gas. Climate scientists tend to see this inclusivity as an evasive maneuver at a time when emissions need to fall rapidly to avoid the most severe impacts from rising temperatures. That's especially true from the US, the country most responsible for historic greenhouse gases and the second-biggest emitter today.

The push for accountability from the US might take on a new dimension at COP29, given US financial support for Ukraine and Israel. "You have money for arms and war," said Amiera Sawas, head of research and policy at the Fossil Fuel Non-Proliferation Treaty Initiative. "It's hard then to also claim you don't have money for the transition."

Read the full story online to see how other countries' relationships with fossil fuel may complicate negotiations at COP29. 

A massive hit 

30%
This is how much climate change could cost world gross domestic product if global warming reaches 3C above pre-industrial levels, according to a report by the Network for Greening the Financial System.

Alone again?

"There was a campaign pushed by the Trump administration to say, 'You ought to join us [in leaving the Paris Agreement] because this isn't a working deal.' And the rest of the world said, 'Actually, we're good here, thank you so much.'"
Jonathan Pershing
Veteran US climate negotiator
If the US were to leave the Paris Agreement again, few -- if any -- countries would follow, according to Pershing. 

Also on the ballot 

By Monique Mulima

In more ways than one, climate is on the ballot this election. With voting on cannabis use in four states, researchers have looked at the  disproportionate environmental footprint of weed production. 

While growing cannabis indoors comes with a high carbon footprint due to heating and lighting, outdoor farming has been criticized for its strain on water resources in drought-prone areas. To mitigate these impacts, growers and retailers are exploring sustainable practices, such as using renewable energy and conserving water. Yet there are major hurdles. Namely the fact that marijuana is illegal under federal law. 

"[W]e cannot have interstate commerce, which means that you are not able to grow cannabis in the sunny, perfect outdoor climates and then ship it around to other states that are less conducive to outdoor growing," said Aaron Smith, chief executive officer of the National Cannabis Industry Association, which represents over 450 businesses.

Photographer: Valeria Mongelli/Bloomberg

Postcard from Paris

By Feargus O'Sullivan

Paris shut its city center to cars on Monday as part of a long series of traffic control and pedestrianization measures in the French capital aimed at reducing congestion and pollution in the heart of the city. And like many of its predecessors, it arrives with some controversy.

The ZTL — Zone à Trafic Limité — will not necessarily turn Paris's core into a car-free fortress. The roughly 100,000 residents who live in these arrondissements will face no new restrictions, and neither will people with disabilities. Buses, taxis and the emergency services are exempt, and so are health care workers, delivery vehicles and some essential workers who will be able to apply for permits.

Enforcement of the zone will also arrive gradually. The first six months will be what Paris police call a "pedagogical period," where rule-breaking vehicles may be stopped and advised of the rules they are breaking. After six months, however, offending drivers will be liable for a fine of €135 ($147 USD).

The ZTL builds on a whole suite of measures introduced by Mayor Anne Hidalgo to reduce automobile traffic and expel the most polluting vehicles from the French capital.

Some motorists may have been caught by surprise by the ZTL this week. The policy's start date was only announced on Thursday, giving drivers little time to prepare.

Pedestrians, cars and bicycles vie for space in Place de la Concorde in 2021.  Photographer: Ludovic Marin/AFP via Getty Images

More from Bloomberg

  • Hyperdrive for expert insight into the future of cars
  • Energy Daily for a daily guide to the energy and commodities markets that power the global economy
  • CityLab Daily for top urban stories and ideas, curated for your inbox by CityLab editors
  • Tech Daily for what to know in tech

Explore all Bloomberg newsletters at Bloomberg.com.

No comments:

Post a Comment

US markets, Bitcoin poised for rally regardless of elections outcome

Fundstrat's Tom Lee sees year-end rally as election uncertainty fades, while Bernstein predicts Bitcoin's resilience and potential g...