Friday, October 4, 2024

A “Holy jobs data, Batman!” moment

Plus: How Reagan and Trump are linked

Conflicting news about the state of the US economy has been roiling politics and consumer sectors for weeks—which makes today's jobs report all the more important. As Bloomberg's Enda Curran writes, we can all breathe a sigh of relief: The news was good. But not all good. Plus: The fairy tale of supply-side economics, and discontent in India over rice policy.

If this email was forwarded to you, click here to sign up.

If you're confused about the state of the American economy, you're not alone. After months of being told that unemployment is increasing and jobs are becoming harder to find, data released on Friday morning eviscerated many of those concerns.

Companies hired a much higher than expected 254,000 workers in September, and revisions to the previous two month's data showed they employed an extra 72,000 workers that hadn't originally been counted. The unemployment rate fell to 4.1% and hourly earnings rose 4% from a year earlier.

Consider this: The number of job losers (or people being laid off) actually declined in the month. The data set for "Job losers and persons who completed temporary jobs" fell by 95,000. Leisure and hospitality operators added 78,000 jobs, and there were an extra 25,000 construction jobs.

If it all felt like a "Holy jobs data, Batman!" moment, that's because it was. KPMG Chief Economist Diane Swonk described the data as "stunning." Neil Dutta, head of economics at Renaissance Macro Research, sent out a reaction note with the all-caps subject line: "WOW. GOOD NUMBER." JPMorgan Chief US Economist Michael Feroli called it a "dinger of a jobs report."

What does it all mean?

For the Federal Reserve, the robust numbers will allow policymakers to exhale and will take pressure off them to lower rates by another 50 basis points when they meet next month (if they choose to lower at all). Vice President Kamala Harris' campaign will likely seize on these numbers as evidence of adroit management and an economic soft landing.

Still, there remain some hints of caution that not all parts of the economy are as strong as others. The manufacturing sector, for example, shed 7,000 jobs (a point that former President Donald Trump will likely seize on in swing states). Broader data shows that consumers have been spending more cautiously, and small businesses in particular continue to complain about the impact of high interest rates.

One of those sensing a dichotomy in the economy is Russell Breuer, founder and chief executive officer of pet food maker Spot & Tango. Although his business continues to do well, he's hearing from up to three times as many job seekers for his vacant positions as he was a year ago. "We have seen an increase in job applications," Breuer says. "Where other industries are downsizing, we are seeing more demand for open roles that we have."

That doesn't mean a recession is imminent—but it does back up recent data that shows at least some cooling in the labor market.

Small businesses like Spot & Tango, which employs around 130, make up the backbone of US employment. Analysis from the McKinsey Global Institute shows that micro, small and medium-size businesses employ almost 6 in 10 workers and produce almost 40% of value added nationally.

For now, the outlook remains positive. The US has reached a point where inflation is slowing, the economy is growing and interest rates are falling. That's as good an outcome as any policymaker could have hoped for.

Frank Fiorille, vice president of risk and compliance at Paychex, a company that runs payroll and other services for small businesses, says that for all the different signals right now, the smaller employers he does business with are still seeing strong conditions.

"Today has validated it is still pretty good," Fiorille said.

Related: Here Are the Key Takeaways From the US Jobs Report for September

In Brief

'Supply-Side Theory' Endures and Endures

President Ronald Reagan receives the "Official Tax Ax" at a 1985 Republican fundraiser in Birmingham, Alabama. Source: Ronald Reagan Presidential Library

During Donald Trump's 90-minute presidential nomination acceptance speech at the Republican National Convention in July, the falsehoods flew so fast and thick that the most important fact-checking site didn't even notice one of the most outrageous ones—maybe because his party has been repeating it for so long that it's simply taken for granted.

Buried 4,023 words into the 12,187-word address was the statement that after he signed the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act into law in 2017, the federal government "took in more revenues the following year than we did when the tax rate was much higher." In fact, federal revenue remained level in nominal terms, and as a percentage of gross domestic product—the relevant measure—it fell a full percentage point. A 2018 analysis by the nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office estimated that the TCJA would end up costing the US Department of the Treasury $1.9 trillion over 10 years.

Never mind the numbers. Trump's bunkum repeated an article of right-wing faith: Federal tax cuts "pay for themselves," because decreased tax burdens unshackle the economy to be radically more productive. This is no more true today than it was when Ronald Reagan first started making the claim shortly before he first ran for president.

How the idea took root in the Republican Party, and endures despite frequent debunking, makes for an important lesson, the historian Rick Perlstein writes for Businessweek: Tax Cuts Pay for Themselves and Other Fairy Tales

India's Problem: An Overabundance of Rice 

Rice sacks stacked outside a mill in Raipur, Chhattisgarh's capital. Photographer: Abeer Khan/Bloomberg

In the state of Chhattisgarh, some 800 miles southeast of New Delhi, there's so much rice sitting in storage that it's starting to rot.

The situation there is emblematic of much of rural India: Cattle graze next to sacks of grain, piled high and covered in black plastic sheets. At nearby mills, supplies from last year's harvest sit outside, awaiting processing, some of it infested with bugs or spoiled from the monsoon. As of late September, about 3 million metric tons of unprocessed rice was in storage in Chhattisgarh alone, according to people familiar with the matter who weren't authorized to be named.

Images of decaying rice have gone viral on social media, with the country's stockpiles reaching an estimated record amount just as this year's harvest was set to begin.

In May 2022, to keep domestic prices in check and ensure a steady supply for a program that provides free grain for 800 million people, Prime Minister Narendra Modi began imposing restrictions on food exports, at first banning shipments of wheat and later adding curbs on rice and sugar. The moves by India, the world's leading rice exporter, roiled international markets and angered farmers adversely affected by falling prices.

Modi's government relaxed some of the restrictions in September, but as Pratik Parija writes, the fallout remains: Rotting Rice in India Fuels Discontent About Modi's Food Policy

Oil and War

5%
That's how much the price of crude oil jumped on Thursday after President Joe Biden said the US was discussing whether to support an Israeli attack on Iran's oil infrastructure.

Paradise Lost

"Mud was liquefying around tree bases. You could see the root systems. The ground just gave out."
Eric Becker
Co-founder of the private wealth management firm Cresset
A wave of transplants, including retirees and artists, has transformed western North Carolina, but after Hurricane Helene's historic flooding, a long boom is facing peril. Read the full story.

More From Bloomberg

Like Businessweek Daily? Check out these newsletters:

  • Business of Space for inside stories of investments beyond Earth
  • CFO Briefing for what finance leaders need to know
  • CityLab Daily for today's top stories, ideas and solutions from cities around the world
  • Tech Daily for exclusive reporting and analysis on tech and AI
  • Green Daily for the latest in climate news, zero-emission tech and green finance

Explore all newsletters at Bloomberg.com.

Stay updated by saving our new email address

Our email address is changing, which means you'll be receiving this newsletter from noreply@news.bloomberg.com. Here's how to update your contacts to ensure you continue receiving it:

  • Gmail: Open an email from Bloomberg, click the three dots in the top right corner, select "Mark as important."
  • Outlook: Right-click on Bloomberg's email address and select "Add to Outlook Contacts."
  • Apple Mail: Open the email, click on Bloomberg's email address, and select "Add to Contacts" or "Add to VIPs."
  • Yahoo Mail: Open an email from Bloomberg, hover over the email address, click "Add to Contacts."

No comments:

Post a Comment

Bond traders recalibrate

Good morning and welcome back, it's Ainsley here with all the news you need to start your working week (and to all Sydneysiders ...