Thursday, October 10, 2024

Next China: Déjà Vu

Remembering an epic boom and bust

Welcome to Next China. Each week, we take you inside the economic giant that is China. To subscribe to this newsletter directly, click here.

This week, we delve into China's equities rally, the dispute with the EU over electric vehicles and take a peek over the Great Firewall.

Hi, I'm Allen Wan in Shanghai.

With the Chinese stock market soaring over the past few weeks on President Xi Jinping's stimulus extravaganza and then coughing up some big gains, I can't help but feel a bit of déjà vu.

I was a Bloomberg stocks editor during the boom and bust of 2015, when the Shanghai Composite Index soared above the 5,000 level in June only to tumble more than 40% by late August.

The question on everybody's minds now is whether the world-beating rally this time around is sustainable as a growing list of strategists revise their bearish forecasts.

Or are we back to that fateful summer when Mad Max: Fury Road was on big screens and stocks were suffering through their own post-apocalyptic nightmare that would lead to a lost decade?

The stakes are pretty high this time around. With the world's second-biggest economy in the deflationary doldrums and the government in danger of missing its growth target of about 5% this year, a buoyant stock market would provide a welcome jolt of confidence in the absence of rising incomes and property values.

One reason for optimism now is stocks look cheaper. At the peak in 2015, the Shanghai gauge traded at nearly twice its five-year average. Tech stocks traded at an average of 220 times reported profits even before the peak, blowing away US counterparts at the height of the dot-com bubble in 2000.

"Chinese equities are still not expensive despite the recent melt-up," Bloomberg Opinion columnist Shuli Ren wrote recently.

Goldman Sachs this week upgraded its call on Chinese stocks to overweight, while highlighting cheap valuations. A further 15-20% gain is possible, if the authorities deliver on their policy measures, the bank's strategists wrote.

The extent of the help coming from on high is unclear. A government briefing last month rolling out a host of measures got the excitement started but another one this week that stopped short of offering a large degree of support disappointed investors.

Yet another press conference planned for Saturday by the Ministry of Finance has spurred bets that officials will ride to the rescue. Investors and analysts expect China to deploy as much as 2 trillion yuan ($283 billion) in fresh fiscal stimulus at the briefing.

One trader I used to talk to frequently during those wild days back in 2015 told me this stocks rally could have legs if the government announces sizeable stimulus this weekend. He worried, though, that depending too much on what officials roll out isn't exactly a healthy way to develop a market.

What We're Reading, Listening to and Watching:

Now What?

The European Union's decision to hit Chinese electric vehicles with tariffs has put the ball in Beijing's court. Judging by past performance, Beijing will retaliate. The only questions are when and to what degree.

China already said this week it would probe whether to boost tariffs on imports of Europe's large-engine vehicles and start collecting levies on brandy. It has also said it would investigate pork and dairy products. That gives Beijing a range of options that would affect different parts of Europe.

Those moves came after the European Union decided to impose tariffs of as high as 45% on imports of China's EVs, the biggest escalation in trade tensions between the two sides in years.

Ten countries, including Italy, France and Poland, voted for the tariffs, while Germany pushed hard for a softer approach and voted against the levies along with four other member states. Twelve others, such as Spain, abstained.

Brussels and Beijing will keep talking to find an alternative to the tariffs. The sides are exploring whether a deal can be reached on a way to control prices and volumes of exports in place of the duties. Without a deal, the tariffs are due by November and would be in force for five years.

Pork is likely one of the sectors most vulnerable to China's response. Should Beijing's inquiry lead to tariffs, the impact will be focused on major suppliers like Spain but also Denmark and the Netherlands, which supported the EV decision.

Dairy is also at risk, with the Netherlands, France and Ireland among China's key EU suppliers. The EU is already challenging China's investigation into dairy subsidies at the World Trade Organization — the first time it's taken such action at the start of the inquiry rather than wait for it to result in trade measures against the bloc.

Beijing has also warned that EU will lose investment from Chinese EV firms and the opportunity to transform its own car industry, if the tariffs are adopted.

While the full extent of Beijing's wrath isn't known yet, it's pretty clear that trade tensions with the bloc will persist into the foreseeable future.

    That's Rich

    9
    That's how many new billionaires that China's stocks rally catapulted back into the ranks of the world's wealthiest at one point this week. The wealth gains mark a sharp reversal from the billions that were wiped from the fortunes of many Chinese moguls in recent years due to the real estate crisis and crackdowns on sectors including technology and finance.

    Behind the Great Firewall

    A weekly look at an item that's been big water cooler news in China.

    China just returned from a long break to mark its National Day and then promptly prepared to work on a Saturday – when the Ministry of Finance will hold that much-anticipated press briefing.

    Why's that? Well, thanks for asking.

    Back in the late 1990s, China launched its policy of tiaoxiu, which can be translated to something like "adjusted rest."

    Basically, the policy sees the government rearrange days around public holidays so people get a longer break. So instead of a random day off midweek because a holiday falls on a Thursday, office workers and students get three days in a row off. And the recent National Day break was seven days long.

    The consolidated time off can make it easier for rural migrants to make the long trip home to see relatives on the other side of the country over Lunar New Year, for example.

    Back in 1999 that seemed like a good idea. The country was coming off the Asian Financial Crisis and officials wanted to boost consumption. Travel around China was also a lot harder back then because the high-speed rail network was still in its infancy.

    The trade-off is that people have to work weekend days to make tiaoxiu work. Hence the reason many offices and classrooms will be open this Saturday.

    Working on weekends is just as unpopular in China as it is in many other parts of the world. Much grumbling could be heard last year when the National Day break was followed by a long run of work days.

    The rearranged calendar can cause some confusion, and productivity takes a hit because employees are less than enthused about being at work on what's typically a day of rest.

    There are frequent calls for officials to get rid of tiaoxiu. "I really hate the inhuman practice," one Weibo user said in a fairly representative complaint this year. "Why does the government ignore the voice of the people on this issue?"

    Still, many people like the policy — seven-day breaks sure are good for trips to say, Thailand, Japan or Singapore — and it's unlikely to disappear anytime soon.

    Stay updated by saving our new email address

    Our email address is changing, which means you'll be receiving this newsletter from noreply@news.bloomberg.com. Here's how to update your contacts to ensure you continue receiving it:

    • Gmail: Open an email from Bloomberg, click the three dots in the top right corner, select "Mark as important."
    • Outlook: Right-click on Bloomberg's email address and select "Add to Outlook Contacts."
    • Apple Mail: Open the email, click on Bloomberg's email address, and select "Add to Contacts" or "Add to VIPs."
    • Yahoo Mail: Open an email from Bloomberg, hover over the email address, click "Add to Contacts."

    No comments:

    Post a Comment

    Solana Reached over 100M million active users

    The Daily Leo #570 ͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏     ­͏ ...