Monday, October 14, 2024

Hurricane insurance isn't always fair

Early estimates put the damage from Hurricane Milton in the tens of billions of dollars. It's the latest example of how climate change is ma

Early estimates put the damage from Hurricane Milton in the tens of billions of dollars. It's the latest example of how climate change is making large parts of the planet too expensive to protect. Bloomberg Green has been investigating that risk in this year's "Uncovered" series. 

Today's story is about catastrophe bonds, a clever-sounding insurance solution that's being pitched to developing countries. Yet the instrument can leave the most vulnerable nations out of luck when disaster strikes. 

Click these links to read more "Uncovered" stories. Part 1 looked at the fragility of US "last resort" insurance programs. Part 2 explored the risky business of private climate modeling. For more on how global warming is impacting insurance markets, please subscribe.

The Harsh Reality of Catastrophe Bonds

By Gautam Naik, Jim Wyss and Greg Ritchie

In the hours before Hurricane Milton reached land in Florida last week, a saildrone dispatched into the maelstrom by US government researchers sent back heart-stopping data. Ocean waves driven by supercharged winds had surged to more than 28 feet tall. It was a specter that sent millions of people fleeing for safety.

A restaurant damaged by hurricanes Helene and Milton in St. Pete Beach, Florida. Photographer: Tristan Wheelock/Bloomberg

Three months earlier, lightning flashed and the wind screamed at 200 miles per hour as Stephen Pituch wrestled a 75-ton propeller plane through another mammoth storm — Hurricane Beryl. Pituch is a hurricane hunter, an elite US Air Force pilot who flies into some of the most violent weather on Earth. His plane fell a stomach-churning thousand feet in the early hours of July 3 as it flew into Beryl over the Caribbean Sea.

"We were getting beat up," he says. "I thought it didn't bode well for Jamaica." He was right. Though Beryl only grazed the island's southern shore, it damaged more than 13,500 homes, shredded hospital roofs and left behind $250 million in losses.

A home in Rocky Point that was lifted off its foundation by Beryl. Photographer: Bryan Anselm/Bloomberg

Jamaica's government had prepared for precisely this scenario. So, too, had the insurers and local governments exposed to the recurring storms that batter Florida. Governments in both places had spent millions of dollars on securities called catastrophe bonds, which act as insurance if disaster strikes, and they were relying on those lifelines to fund recovery efforts.

Floridians will get money in line with actual losses. A similar arrangement made by Jamaica didn't help at all. Its government has a catastrophe bond backed by the World Bank that could have yielded a $150 million payout, but it didn't trigger because Beryl's air pressure missed the required threshold by a hair.

That sense of injustice puts into doubt a market-driven tool that's being pitched as a way to protect vulnerable populations against more extreme weather. For years, diplomats have fought bitterly at annual COP climate summits over the need for developed nations to set aside money to assist poorer countries. Now, there are discussions about using some of the limited resources gathered in a loss and damage fund to finance insurance programs that could tap capital markets for greater payouts, according to people familiar with the talks.

Insurers and governments in the wealthy world tend to dislike the binary nature of parametric catastrophe bonds like the one Jamaica deployed. Yet the promise of speedy payouts has persuaded the World Bank and Western governments to push them for the developing world, even as the risk-reward curve shifts in favor of investors in London, New York and Zurich.

Julett Morgan, a 50-year-old vegetable seller whose wood-and-tin shack collapsed in a hard-hit area called Rocky Point southwest of Kingston, didn't know about Jamaica's cat bond. But as she surveyed the damage around her, from ripped roofs to toppled homes, it seemed inconceivable that an insurance policy, of any variety, wouldn't pay something. "My house was flat, flat, flat," she says. "The storm took furniture, clothes, everything. I've never seen anything like it."

Read the full story about how one of Wall Street's favorite climate bets works differently for rich and poor countries on Bloomberg.com

Investors take a hit

1.34%
Estimate by Artemis of how much the catastrophe bond market dipped after Milton. It's a smaller decline than initially expected, but is likely to raise risk premiums anyway.

Supercharged storm

"Without climate change Milton would have made landfall as a Category 2 instead of a Category 3 storm."
World Weather Attribution
A group of scientists that studies extreme weather events to detect the impact of global warming.

Weather Watch 

By Yinka Ibukun, Diakaridia Dembele and Tanga Kafando

West Africa's coastal nations are bracing for deadly floods from their northern neighbors to sweep south, but money is tight and they face double jeopardy from rain as the wet season sets in.

Nigeria, Togo, Benin and Ghana warned residents to be prepared after record-breaking rains hit the adjacent Sahel region last month, killing 1,000 people and affecting more than 5 million across West and Central Africa.

Poor drainage and heavier-than-usual rains risk a repeat, said Kiswendsida Guigma, a meteorologist at the Red Cross Crescent Climate Center in Ouagadougou, Burkina Faso.

Flooding in Maiduguri, Nigeria, on Sept 10. Photographer: Musa Ajit Borno/AP

Worth a Listen

Catastrophe bonds are a specialized insurance tool that can help people who've lost their homes find money to rebuild – or deliver big profits to investors who are willing to gamble on big climate-linked disasters. Bloomberg's Gautam Naik tells Akshat Rathi about how these instruments differ from ordinary insurance, and why they have become an appealing proposition for climate vulnerable nations. Listen now, and subscribe on Apple,  Spotify, or YouTube to get new episodes of Zero every Thursday.

More from Bloomberg

  • Hyperdrive for expert insight into the future of cars
  • Energy Daily for a daily guide to the energy and commodities markets that power the global economy
  • CityLab Daily for top urban stories and ideas, curated for your inbox by CityLab editors
  • Tech Daily for what to know in tech

Explore all Bloomberg newsletters at Bloomberg.com.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Stressed? In this country, help is just a call away

A new hotline View in browser Hi, it's Karoline in Singapore, a high-stress financial center w...