Thursday, June 1, 2023

FDA considers a drug with mixed results

A tough decision for the FDA

Hi, it's Angelica in Boston. Families are pleading with the FDA to approve a gene therapy for a debilitating genetic disease. But first…

Today's must-reads

  • A little-known animal tranquilizer is accelerating the deadly US opioid epidemic.
  • Climate change has become a forceful driver of migration in Latin America.
  • A report that tracks the amount of coffee in warehouses at US ports has been pulled, making it harder to determine how much Americans are drinking.

Families vs. the FDA 

Sheila Ungerer started noticing something was amiss with her son Will when he was 3 years old. He couldn't jump with both feet, which she thought might just be a developmental delay. 

But within minutes of an exam, a doctor told Ungerer and her husband that their son had a more serious problem. A genetic test confirmed the diagnosis: Duchenne muscular dystrophy, a disease that primarily affects boys and causes their muscles to weaken over time. Most patients die in their 20s. 

The diagnosis was an "unexpectedly horrible bit of news," Ungerer says. A few years later, then 5-year-old Will received the opportunity to enroll in a clinical trial of a gene therapy from Sarepta Therapeutics. The one-time treatment promises to help patients produce a protein similar to the one they lack.

While the Ungerers didn't find out for sure that Will received the therapy for a few years, almost immediately they felt pretty sure he got the real thing. Within weeks, he was sitting upside down on the couch and running up to the top of a hill before rolling down it. Now 9, Will swims on a team and plays tag at recess. He can jump with two feet now, though he won't play soccer. But that's OK. 

Ungerer recently shared Will's story at a meeting of independent experts advising the FDA on whether to approve the gene therapy. Will's story and others about boys who received Sarepta's drug helped convince the panel to narrowly recommend approving the treatment despite concerns the data doesn't exactly match those anecdotes. 

In the trial Will participated in, Sarepta's therapy didn't clearly beat the placebo. FDA reviewers also worry the protein the therapy elicits isn't the same as the natural protein. Since patients may have only one shot at receiving gene therapy, the stakes are especially high.  

The FDA is in a tough spot. Patients and families are desperate for new treatments, even imperfect ones. 

"From my perspective, it's like, approve it," Ungerer says. "Let it go and let them do it and let it help people in the way that it helps Will because it's worth it."

Sarepta is currently running a larger trial that aims to answer definitively whether the therapy benefits patients. Results won't be available until later this year, and the FDA is expected to rule on Sarepta's application for an accelerated approval this month.

The agency appears poised to clear the therapy only for children between 4 and 5 years old who saw the best response in the trials, a move that could help the FDA strike a balance. Either way, people on both sides of the debate will probably be dissatisfied. Angelica Peebles 

What we're reading

Thousands of people with chronic pain were implanted with a component of a medical device that might not do anything but make the company more money, Stat News reports.

Metapneumovirus, or HMPV, is the most important virus you've never heard of, CNN writes.

The deadliest time for moms is after their baby is born, a surprising finding that's changing maternal health care, according to the New York Times.  

Ask Prognosis

Ask us anything — well, anything health-related that is! Each week we're picking a reader question and putting it to our network of experts. So get in touch via AskPrognosis@bloomberg.net.

No comments:

Post a Comment

This rare event could mint millionaires in 2025

Get ready for a DRAMATIC shift now headed for U.S. stocks                                                                                   ...