Monday, March 6, 2023

No transition without transmission

By Brian Eckhouse, Naureen S Malik and Dave MerrillThe biggest impediment to the US achieving a cleaner power grid isn't climate deniers or

By Brian Eckhouse, Naureen S Malik and Dave Merrill

The most important clean energy investment is having a moment

The biggest impediment to the US achieving a cleaner power grid isn't climate deniers or fossil-fuel lobbies; it's a lack of transmission lines. The country badly needs more conduits to cart wind and solar energy and hydropower to cities.

For more than a decade, multibillion-dollar power-line projects have struggled to advance, slowed or halted by bureaucracy, NIMBYism or general industry stasis. Now suddenly, several are progressing — and with them the prospect of newly unleashed clean energy as well as more resilient grids in the face of ever-dangerous storms and extreme heatwaves.

There's SunZia in the Southwest, TransWest Express in the Mountain West, Grain Belt Express to the Midwest, and Champlain Hudson Power Express into New York City — projects that together will cost at least $13 billion. Some are now ordering expensive equipment, a signal of their advancement. SunZia and TransWest expect to begin construction this year.

"All of a sudden things are happening," says transmission pioneer Michael Skelly.

There are no assurances that the next generation of power lines won't run into the same obstacles as the projects that are now blooming. That's the risk of transmission development: Since even the most successful projects take years to build, there's ample time for opponents or skeptics to impede them. That threatens to dampen America's clean-energy swagger after the signing last summer of the Inflation Reduction Act, President Joe Biden's landmark climate law.

The fact these long-in-the-works projects are reaching similar milestones appears to be coincidence; no single policy is moving them forward. They are, however, advancing at a time of increasing understanding by local communities and even traditional opponents — including some conservation groups — of the need to move clean energy from rural outposts and to build more durable electric systems after a series of weather and climatic events have felled grids in recent years.

"There is no transition without transmission – that's my new mantra," says Rob Gramlich, founder of Grid Strategies LLC, a power-sector consulting firm.

On the latest episode of Getting Warmer, Kal Penn explores how the western US can cope with a long-term megadrought and whether recycled wastewater is a solution to the world's limited water supply. Stream online from Bloomberg Originals on Apple TV, Roku, Samsung TV, Fire TV or Android TV.

For clean-power advocates, there's more good news. While long-distance power lines are tedious to get permitted and approved, building transmission is now a top priority for the US renewable industries. A dozen years ago, solar was still fledgling in the country, and the sector was most focused on securing long-term tax credits. With the Inflation Reduction Act, it finally has that. (A related benefit for the industries: transmission developers now have confidence that solar or wind projects that may be five years away from operations will actually use their lines, providing some needed revenue assurance).

Some projects that are moving ahead support California or New York, two of the most progressive states, either directly or indirectly. That's probably not an accident. Both may need some clean power generated from outside of their territories to help meet climate goals.

https://www.bloomberg.com/green-zero-emissions-podcast
On Zero, Akshat Rathi asks UNDP head Achim Steiner about the opportunities and threats climate change poses to development, how countries can plan for climate refugees, and what rising inequality means for a world facing multiple crises. Listen now — and subscribe on AppleSpotify, or Google to get new episodes every Thursday.

Pattern Energy's SunZia project is designed to transport more than three gigawatts of clean power — equivalent to about three nuclear reactors — from New Mexico to Arizona, where it can then flow to the West Coast. "It will unlock resources to places that really need it," says Cary Kottler, the company's chief development officer.

The $6 billion Champlain Hudson Power Express, a Blackstone Group-backed project to bring Canadian hydropower to New York City, would be the longest high-voltage direct current, or HVDC, line built underground in the US, according to Don Jessome, who has worked on the development since 2008 and is a member of the CHPE board of directors. HVDC has long tantalized clean energy and grid-reliability advocates — as just 3% of the electricity is lost moving power hundreds of miles versus up to 30% for conventional technology, according to Jessome — but transmission development tends to be decentralized in the US, limiting what the federal government can do.

Jessome says one reason more power lines may be on the way is people are seeing the effects of climate change "much sooner" than they thought. "That helps with the narrative to build transmission," he says. "It's going to impact people's lives not 50 years from now, but 5, 10 years from now."

Like getting the Green Daily? Subscribe to Bloomberg.com for unlimited access to breaking news on climate and energy, data-driven reporting and graphics and Bloomberg Green magazine. Read and share this story on the web.

Reaching the Sun

152 million
This many kilometers of power lines are needed for the world to reach net zero by 2050, according to analysis by BloombergNEF.

Changing views

"People see that renewable energies are key to more independence."
Katja Witte
Energy sociologist at the Wuppertal Institute
NIMBYs and bureaucracy have also held back high-voltage power lines in Germany. The energy crisis has helped raise acceptance for transmission projects.

More from Green

United Nations delegates reached an agreement on Saturday that could mark the end of unregulated exploitation of the ocean. If ratified, the UN high seas biodiversity treaty would establish marine protected areas, where fishing could be banned, and create new hurdles for corporations operating on the high seas, including for those companies proposing to remove carbon dioxide from the ocean. Read more here

Photographer: EVA HAMBACH/AFP
  • Climate change may cost Germany up to €900 billion by 2050. A new report finds crop failures, production or supply chain disruptions and infrastructural damages are just a few of the climate-related risks.
     
  • Paris plans to transform its last natural fridge. An abandoned tunnel in the city once known as "the world's wine cellar" could now be used as a cooling shelter during heat waves, according to one ecologist. 
     
  • Climate change is launching a mutant seed space race. The world's nuclear watchdog is exposing seeds to orbital radiation in an experiment to trigger resistance against global warming.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Must Read: The Fed’s Favorite Inflation Report Is in. Here’s What We Learned…

Yesterday, we got a fresh look at the latest Federal Reserve's preferred inflation gauge for August... ...