The question on Monday was whether there was a hangover cure strong enough to end the market rout that began on Friday and got much worse when Asian markets opened late on Sunday (worrying traders more than a far-right win in Italy). Traders, analysts and politicians looking for a soothing balm had been surprised on Sunday to hear Kwarteng's commitment "more is to come." Sterling dropped further and then, while the UK was sleeping, its currency tumbled in Asian markets — to £1.03 to the dollar, something former Treasury officials I know didn't think they'd ever see. And so, even though the pound pared its losses slightly, the Bank of England came under huge pressure to do something. Anything. A likely whopping 100 basis-point hike in November was already priced in. By Monday this climbed to 200 basis-points — four times the size of its last hike — and a call for an extraordinary extra session hastily arranged for this week. By lunchtime, there was a rumour of a BOE statement within hours, possibly including a extra bonus rate hike. In the end this didn't materialise and all we got was the emollient tweet featured at the top of this email. Most agree the Bank will raise rates again — hammering household mortgage repayments in a period already billed as the worst winter in living memory (something former minister Jim O'Neill weighed in on today, calling the Budget "naive.") So, if higher rates are one near cert response, what else did people prescribe? In an interview with Bloomberg Radio, one of the godfathers of Trussonomics, Gerald Lyons, believes it is a matter of explaining better the full policy context to Friday's package. "[Kwarteng] needs to reaffirm that tax cuts are only part of the story, not the full story. What they're following is a supply-side agenda. Markets were still not convinced that his fiscal easing was necessary, non-inflationary and affordable... It's quite clear from the market reaction that those concerns were not fully addressed."
But our political editor and team have found plenty of Tory backbenchers horrified at the pound heading to parity with the dollar. One told them that "Kwarteng and Truss are in the midst of an ideological low-tax obsession, which won't deliver growth quickly enough to stabilize the public finances." Over in the US, Tyler Cowen gives us a much needed contrarian take arguing there is no evidence the UK can't or won't repay its debts; nor are the yields on British government securities "astronomical numbers." He reserves more criticism for the BOE. "Politics aside, this is hardly the stuff from which economic disasters are made. What this debate could use is fewer adjectives and more numbers." But Bloomberg Opinion's editorial board is less relaxed, calling for the prime minister to address a perceived reputation for recklessness: "Following this worst possible start to her premiership, Truss needs to understand what went wrong and take prompt corrective action … Truss had already built a reputation for recklessness. The new fiscal policy seemed to affirm it. She must put this right in short order, or things will go from bad to worse." |
No comments:
Post a Comment